Lessons from Tuesday’s election

You may have focused on the top races for control of the Senate or governorships across the county, but oil and gas drilling was on the ballot too. Today I’ll catch you up on a few ballot measures that will have an impact on the future of oil and gas drilling along the Beartooth Front  and across the country.

Mike Wheat. Click to enlarge.

Mike Wheat. Click to enlarge.

First, Montanans showed the good sense to return state Supreme Court Justice Mike Wheat to the bench by a margin of 59% – 41%. Outside corporate interests wound up spending over $500,000 to replace Wheat with an unqualified judge who was committed to follow an agenda driven in part by the oil and gas industry.

Carbon and Stillwater Counties agreed, by slightly smaller margins:

Wheat_CarbonWheat_StillwaterA great outcome that holds promise for making sure that Montana’s approach to oil and gas drilling balances the needs of communities and the environment with those of the oil and gas industry.

In other Montana election news of concern to readers of this blog, Yellowstone County incumbent Virginia Court defeated Tom Richmond in Montana House District 50. Court, who has served in the House since 2011, is a successful small business owner who supports a sound economy, a good education system, and clean water and air. Readers will remember Tom Richmond as the longtime administrator of the Montana Board of Oil and Gas Conservation (BOGC) who offended so many local residents when he spoke at the Elks Club in Red Lodge last January, and who was instrumental in denying Silvertip residents the opportunity to testify against the permitting of an oil well in Belfry. Good choice, Yellowstone County.

Denton, Texas
Nationally, the most visible victory of the night came in Denton, Texas, located in the middle of the rich Barnett Shale. Last summer the local city council refused to act on citizen concerns about the dangers of fracking. Undeterred, the citizens went to the ballot to pass a fracking ban.

Denton fracking banThe oil companies pumped huge amounts of money into the campaign and threatened to sue if the initiative passed. But the measure won 59% – 41%, making Denton the first city in the largest oil and gas producing state in the county to pass such a ban.

A lesson for elected officials in Texas, but for Montana County Commissioners as well: private land owners who demand to control what happens on their own property should be ignored at your own risk.

Athens, Ohio
Athens became Ohio’s fifth city to ban fracking Tuesday when voters approved a local ordinance to ban the practice inside the city limits.

The Athens Community Bill of Rights passed with about 78 percent of voters casting ballots in favor.

The measure modifies Athens municipal laws to prohibit shale gas and oil extraction and related activities.

Other Ohio cities that have passed Bill of Rights fracking bans include Oberlin, Cincinnati, Broadview Heights and Yellow Springs.

Mendocino, California
In Mendocino County in northern California, residents also adopted a “Community Bill of Rights” law banning fracking by a vote of 67% – 33%. California’s deep drought and Mendocino’s location on a major earthquake fault were the deciding factors for local residents.

What makes these Bill of Rights initiatives of particular interest to Montanans is that the initiative establishes the rights of the people of Mendocino County to a “healthy environment,” including clean air and water. Fracking is banned as a violation of that right. The extraction or sale of local water for use in fracking anywhere in the state is also banned, along with the dumping of toxic fracwater.

Article 2, Section 3 of the Montana Constitution establishes the “inalienable right” of citizens

to a clean and healthful environment and the rights of pursuing life’s basic necessities, enjoying and defending their lives and liberties, acquiring, possessing and protecting property, and seeking their safety, health and happiness in all lawful ways.

The similarities are striking. You have to wonder whether this right might be a future reason to ban fracking.

San benito county fracking banSan Benito County, California
In rural San Benito County, located just south of Silicon Valley, the oil and gas industry spent nearly $2 million, fifteen times more than the group in favor of the ban.

Although there is currently no fracking in the county, the industry was clearly concerned about the precedent it would set. The initiative passed 57% – 43%.

“This is a testament to the power of ordinary people when they decide to determine
their own future,” said Andy Hsia-Coron, one of the leaders of the Coalition to
Protect San Benito. “Millions were spent to confuse the people of our county and it
didn’t work. Now we can export hope to communities far and wide who believe that
the people not outside corporations should be in charge.”

Some bans failed on Tuesday
However, not all proposed fracking bans were successful on Tuesday. In Santa Barbara, California, where there is already extensive offshore oil drilling, voters sent Measure P to a decisive 63% – 37% defeat.

Local oil producers threatened lawsuits against Santa Barbara County if Measure P succeeded. And Californians for Energy Independence, an industry group with major funding from Chevron and Aera Energy, funneled $7.6 million against the initiative. Overall the industry outspent initiative proponents 20-1.

Three other Ohio cities — Gates Mills, Kent, and Youngstown — turned down similar fracking bans to the one in Athens.

What it means for the Beartooth Front
Right now there are no movements to impose fracking bans along the Beartooth Front similar to the ones that were passed Tuesday. Local citizen groups are working with County Commissioners to establish citizen initiated zones that will define the legal requirements for how and where drilling will take place.

Citizens have consciously adopted this balanced approach to find solutions that are fair to land owners who are concerned about damage to their property and livelihood from drilling, yet want to be respectful of the rights of their neighbors who might benefit from mineral extraction.

Click to view full letter

Click to view full letter

However, ballot initiatives could take place in the future, particularly if oil companies place legal roadblocks in the way of this fundamental citizen right, or if the County Commissioners choose to ignore the legal right of citizens to take this action.

Energy Corporation of America has threatened to pursue legal action outlined in the letter at right, if the Carbon County Commissioners work with local citizens to establish a citizen initiated zone.

It is clear that citizens across the United States are recognizing the dangers of oil and gas drilling more clearly, and are beginning to take action to protect themselves. Communities in Carbon and Stillwater Counties, recognizing those same dangers, are taking a different path, but one that leads the door open to more comprehensive measures if necessary.

I’ll be writing more in the future about these community bill of rights initiatives.

About davidjkatz

The Moses family has lived on the Stillwater River since 1974, when George and Lucile Moses retired and moved to the Beehive from the Twin Cities. They’re gone now, but their four daughters (pictured at left, on the Beehive) and their families continue to spend time there, and have grown to love the area. This blog started as an email chain to keep the family informed about the threat of increased fracking activity in the area, but the desire to inform and get involved led to the creation of this blog.
This entry was posted in Community Organization, Politics and History and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Lessons from Tuesday’s election

  1. wilderld says:

    it is nice to know that money cannot buy ALL elections. It is so important to have fair, experienced and deliberate judges in our highest courts.

    • Thanks goodness citizens voted NO to Tom Richmond, who’s been and industry puppet for years. He’s never insisted that the BOAG MUST have more inspectors to match the explosion of drilling operations. How can he – with a straight face – accept that 8 inspectors adequate!!?? Would Montana parents accept having no referees for their kids basketball teams because one town had one referee and others go without? Does
      it take that kind of IMPACT to get folks to Wake TF up?

  2. Arleen Boyd says:

    Thank you for what you do. You have stepped up in such an important way.


  3. Bush parasites – Cheney, Baker and such ilk – now SUING the City of Denton’s new ban on fracking, and shows just how corrupt Bush and Cheney really are. Note, Cheney engineered the
    oil and gas industry’s gift of in 2005 legislation that didn’t hold them accountable under the Clean Air and Water Acts, another sleazy Cheney ploy while we were distracted and divided by an disastrous Cheney adventure into Iraq.

    The MT Supreme Court matters, as they ruled in 2010 that Cascade County – doing SME’s bidding (Beartooth co-op folks can thank SME for their staggering electric rates, and why Yellowstone Valley co-op fled SME in 2009) – LOST when court ruled the county engaged in ILLEGAL SPOT ZONING. Elections MATTER, even at you county commission.

    PS – Arleen Boyd a real hero, speaking Truth to Power and serving Beartooth Electric Co-op with courage and integrity.

  4. Pingback: Denton, Texas lawsuit: lessons for the Beartooth Front | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  5. Pingback: A personal story: Cathy McMullen, Denton Texas | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  6. Pingback: Texas legislature seeks to undermine Denton fracking ban | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  7. Pingback: Editorial: Fracking bill sets dangerous precedent (with video) | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  8. Pingback: Now a law: Texas measure makes local oil regulation illegal (with NPR audio) | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  9. Pingback: You’ve probably never heard of the Wilks brothers. They’re about to take away your property rights. | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  10. Pingback: Lessons from other states: Colorado | Preserve the Beartooth Front

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s