Landowners show up for hearing on Beartooth Front lawsuit

There was a familiar look to the gallery at the hearing Thursday in the Stillwater County Courthouse in Columbus. In the case of Beartooth Front Coalition et al vs. Stillwater County Commissioners, there were, by my count, 56 people there in support of the Beartooth Front Coalition, which is suing Stillwater County to establish a citizen-initiated zone to regulate land use related to oil and gas along the Beartooth Front.

They were easy to identify. They all knew each other. They are neighbors in southern Stillwater County who signed a petition to establish the zone. They greeted each other by name, offered encouragement, expressed resolve to be successful in the suit.

Local landowners showed up in force to observe the hearing.

There were also three journalists, representing the Billings Gazette and the Stillwater County News.

And who was there representing the mineral rights owners who are at the heart of the case? Only the four defendants — Stillwater County Commissioners Maureen Davey, Mark Crago, and Dennis Shupak,  and County Clerk Heidi Staidl — and their hired gun attorney from Cheyenne.

The Commissioners adopted a novel theory in rejecting the petition, suggesting that it was not sufficient that 60% of these neighbors – over 550 of them – signed the petition, as required by law. They rejected the petition because they said that the law requires the signatures of 60% of the subsurface owners as well, even though no county had required this for any of the 111 previous citizen-initiated zones in Montana. The landowners filed suit in February.

There was a heavy irony in this. Here they were – four elected officials fighting in court against the people who voted for them and who pay their salaries, fighting to protect the rights of people who don’t live in Stillwater County and who they don’t even know. The minerals owners are, of course, proxies for the oil and gas industry, who the Commissioners have decided to represent against their natural constituents.

The landowners care enough to show up
It was not surprising that the landowners came out in force against nameless and faceless opposition. At every previous opportunity for public input into this process, the landowners stepped up to support the petition, and nobody showed up in opposition.

At a public hearing on zoning in March, 2017, 23 people braved wintry weather to speak in support of citizen-initiated zoning. Nobody spoke against. At a hearing on the Commissioners’ proposed new policy on citizen-initiated zoning in March of this year, 25 speakers spoke against the policy, which would have required the signatures of minerals owners, and nearly 50 wrote letters in opposition. Nobody showed up to speak in favor of the policy or wrote in support.

The hearing
The hearing itself was one-sided, and Judge Blair Jones left no doubt as to how he planned to rule. The Cheyenne attorney had filed a motion asking Judge Jones to decide the case in favor of the Commissioners because she claimed that Montana state law does not allow counties to regulate oil and gas, that this is reserved only for the Montana Board of Oil and Gas Conservation. Kim Wilson, the landowners’ attorney, argued that it was impossible to say whether any regulations are legal because there are no regulations – the Commissioners have not formed the zone, which would have to happen before the court could look at whether they were legal or not.

Judge Jones sided with Wilson, responding that the court was not in the business of issuing speculative rulings, and that he couldn’t imagine doing so. He said he looked forward to arguing the real issue in the case, whether minerals owners have a say in land use decisions related to oil and gas extraction. He promised to issue a ruling on the Commissioners’ motion soon, but it is clear that he is going to deny it.

Wilson, the landowners’ attorney, said he planned to file a motion for summary judgment on behalf of the landowners within the next few weeks. This will be the primary motion in the case, litigating who has a right to determine what happens along the surface of the Beartooth Front.

After the hearing the neighbors retired to the hallway outside the courtroom to exchange greetings and congratulate each other on a successful day in court. The Commissioners went back to their offices alone, none willing to venture out to speak to their constituents.

This is going to be a long process. There will be other days in court on this case, some perhaps more difficult than this one. But there is no doubt the landowners are resolved to fight as long as it takes to protect their rights. The issue for them is personal. This is their land, their community, their livelihoods. The Commissioners, for their part, seem determined to fight against their taxpayers to protect the oil and gas industry. It is much less clear what drives them. I wonder if they know themselves.

About davidjkatz

The Moses family has lived on the Stillwater River since 1974, when George and Lucile Moses retired and moved to the Beehive from the Twin Cities. They’re gone now, but their four daughters (pictured at left, on the Beehive) and their families continue to spend time there, and have grown to love the area. This blog started as an email chain to keep the family informed about the threat of increased fracking activity in the area, but the desire to inform and get involved led to the creation of this blog.
This entry was posted in Legal and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to Landowners show up for hearing on Beartooth Front lawsuit

  1. wilderld says:

    I continue to be amazed that the county commissioners are determined to silence the voices of their constituents–the taxpayers who pay their salaries.

  2. Sally Ann Bisch says:

    What is the incentive for the County Commissioners to fight the local landowners? Have they been influenced in some way by the
    by the oil and gas companies?

    • davidjkatz says:

      I think that’s a question they need to answer. The landowners began working on establishing this zone in 2013. At no point have the Commissioners engaged in any meaningful way, or stated their objections to setting reasonable limits on drilling in this very vulnerable area.

      At this point our recourse is to use the legal system to force them to deal with us, and that’s what we plan to do.

  3. Barbara Van Cleve says:

    Unfortunately this business of elected officials fighting the desires/intents of their constituents seems to be epidemic here in Montana as well as the nation. It seems to me that it might be possible to sue the individual members of the county commission. That might bring them to their senses individually. Is there money being passed under the table or what? Why on earth would they want to allow fracking in such a sensitive area? Are they stupid or have they swallowed – hook, line and sinker – the erroneous “facts” put forth by the gas and oil industry there as to the safety of fracking in that area?

  4. Pingback: Beartooth Front landowners win first round of lawsuit | Beartooth Front Coalition

  5. Pingback: Beartooth Front landowners win first round of lawsuit | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  6. Pingback: Beartooth landowners file motion for summary judgment in zoning lawsuit | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  7. Pingback: Stillwater County landowner lawsuit update: County runs out the clock on Judge Jones; hearing set for January 16 | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  8. Pingback: Action alert: New developments in landowner lawsuit against Stillwater County; what you can do to help | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  9. Pingback: Action alert: Your attendance needed at Stillwater County Planning Board meeting, July 3, 2019 | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  10. Pingback: Must attend! Stillwater County Planning Board: Wednesday, August 7, 7pm | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  11. Pingback: Action alert: Stillwater County Planning Board meeting, Wed, 9/4, 7pm | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  12. Pingback: Action alert: Watch court hearing on Zoom, Thursday, 2:00 pm | Preserve the Beartooth Front

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s