Fracking News from California and I Find Out About Flaring

20 top climate scientists have called on California Governor Jerry Brown to ban fracking in California.  Article here. Actual letter here. It’s an impressive group of scientists, and the environmental argument is pretty simple:

“If what we’re trying to do is stop using the sky as a waste dump for our carbon pollution, and if we’re trying to transform our energy system, the way to do that is not by expanding our fossil fuel infrastructure,” said Ken Caldeira, an atmospheric scientist at the Carnegie Institution for Science at Stanford University.

Some local entities in New Mexico and New York have already banned fracking, although the oil and gas industry is busily challenging these bans.

Flaring

When you think about fracking, you have to recognize that it doesn’t all happen underground. Here‘s an article in National Geographic that describes the process of “flaring,” the deliberate open air burning of natural gas. While flaring is superior in terms of carbon emissions to the open burning of methane, it releases carbon into the atmosphere. From the article, here’s what you can expect to see around the hydraulic fracturing wells in Montana:

A natural gas flare illuminates discarded vehicles and farm tools.

Even more disturbing, here’s a space photo of flaring in the Bakken:

A satellite view of gas flaring in North Dakota.

Gas flares, not city lights, shine through the night sky in this satellite view of western North Dakota.

Image courtesy NASA Earth Observatory

Posted in Community Organization, Politics and History | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Montana Environmental Information Center

I checked out the Montana Environmental Information Center, the organization that Sam mentioned. Here’s there fracking page, where you can also sign up for information updates in the upper right corner.

The news on the page about legislation isn’t so great. We’re going to have to get to work:

How Fracking is Regulated in Montana

The practice of fracking is largely unregulated at the federal level. Fracking was exempted from the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) through the so-called “Halliburton Amendment,” a product of Dick Cheney’s vice-presidential Energy Task Force. However, the Energy Policy Act of 2005 requires regulation of fracking operations under SDWA if diesel fuel is used as a fracking fluid additive. As of Fall 2011, the U.S. EPA was studying the implementation of diesel fracking rules, although many operators consider diesel fuel to be substandard compared to other additives for many frack operations.

During the 2011 Montana legislative session, there were several proposals to increase the regulation of fracking in Montana, but they were all tabled in committee at the request of the industry. In August 2011 the BOGC adopted a fracking fluid disclosure rule. This rule was aimed at protecting public health by making the contents of fracking fluid known to the public and interested parties for review. Although the rule is a step forward in disclosure, it is inadequate. Importantly, it does not require prior notification for adjacent landowners of well fracking. This is important because landowners need to have adequate time to obtain baseline water testing. The rule also contains a very broad trade-secret exemption that allows the industry to keep the chemical concentrations and mixtures a secret.

– See more at: http://meic.org/issues/oil-and-gas-in-montana/fracking-in-montana/#sthash.YCLty2JX.dpuf

 

 

 

 

Posted in Community Organization, Politics and History, Fracking Information | Tagged | Leave a comment

Communication from Cousin Sam

Hello all!

I apologize for my radio silence on the issue so far; I’ve just moved and started a new job and have had precious little time to spare for anything else.  I’ve done some work on fracking issues in California and followed the debate for a while and have seen few, if any, better explanations of the dangers of fracking than those offered by David in this thread. Big kudos for a very comprehensive and palatable explanation.

A few thoughts that I have coming out of what I’ve learned here:

1. I think that the best way of catching up on an issue like this is to look to other groups that have studied it for a while. Reaching out to groups like the NPRC is a great way of learning where we stand politically and therefor finding the best angle from which to approach a decision maker. I’m also eagerly awaiting results of this NPRC meeting. If you haven’t signed up for email updates from them, I highly recommend it. The Montana Environmental Information Center, headed by  Derf Johnson, also has an email list and some resources on fracking.

2. Google alerts are great. Plug something like “fracking Montana” into google news and sign up for a daily update with any stories that include those key words. It seems like things are happening pretty fast right now.

3. Petitions are great, but they aren’t the most focused way of reaching the people that you want to hear the message. If we can find or put together a chart of decision makers on the issue in Montana (NPRC, or maybe some legwork on our side) it would be beneficial to reach out to them directly. In a relatively small state like Montana I would think that elected officials, be it the Attorney General or state legislators, would be receptive to letters written by constituents. This also goes for letters to the editor; the letters to the editor page is a great place to get free coverage and reach a lot of people (second highest readership in newspapers after obits). My father has a lot of experience with that, and I can also share some tips on how to get LTEs published if anyone wants them.

4. I’ve passed along a lot of these emails to a friend of mine who will be visiting Montana soon on behalf of Environment America, working (most likely) on clean water issues. She’s happy to have some background on the issue and might be doing outreach to a lot of the same people that we are. I’ll keep y’all up to date with anything that I hear from her camp.

Much love to all, and thank you for your reasoned and quick response to the issue.

Posted in Community Organization, Politics and History, Fracking Information | Leave a comment
The more I read, the more I understand that the arena in which we need to engage is political..The dailykos blog post below is a very well-documented story of a guy in Texas who is being hounded by the fracking company and the State of Texas because he has claimed (apparently with clear justification) that the fracking process has contaminated his water. The fracking company has filed a $3 million defamation suit against the guy with the apparent complicity of the Texas courts and the federal Environmental Protection Agency.

As much of a horror story as this is, it makes it clear that the path to managing fracking in the Beartooths is through the Montana State Legislature. Unlike Texas, they are going to have to institute controls with bear teeth to control environmental, economic and social implementation of new drilling.

Looking forward to hearing what Big Jane learns at the NPRC meeting this weekend.

Here‘s the blog post. An interesting and disturbing read. If you don’t have time to read it, check out the video of this guy (the one sued by the energy company for defamation) lighting his water on fire.

Posted on by davidjkatz | Leave a comment

Explosion in the Bakken

From the November 7 Bismarck Tribune:
Saltwater disposal explosion

Photo courtesy of JERRY SAMUELSON, McKenzie County Emergency Manager

An explosion on a treater at a saltwater disposal well southwest of Alexander Thursday dumped 2,710 barrels of saltwater and crude on site and destroyed all the storage tanks.

 
23 hours ago  •  By Lauren Donovan

A noontime explosion at a saltwater disposal well site Thursday near Alexander dumped 2,440 barrels of saltwater and 270 barrels of oil and destroyed 13 storage tanks at a disposal facility owned by Mesa Oil Services.

McKenzie County Emergency Manager Jerry Samuelson said the cause of the explosion was not known.

Samuelson said a tanker driver had just unloaded at the disposal site when the treater exploded, setting fire to the adjacent storage tanks. A treater is a piece of equipment that uses heat to separate out oil.

Posted in Bakken | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Article on Williston, ND in The Week

From The Week magazine, 10/19/2013

North Dakota: Trouble in boomtown
North Dakota is in the midst of an oil boom that has generated enormous wealth — and some big problems, too
By Dan Stewart | October 19, 2013
More oil, more money, more problems.
More oil, more money, more problems. (Andrew Burton/Getty Images)
 
W

When did the boom begin?
About seven years ago. Geologists have known about the Bakken shale foundation, one of the largest oil and natural gas deposits in the world, since the early 1950s. But oil production in the state was slow to develop because it was too difficult and costly to get at the deposits, which are trapped between compressed layers of rock. But as oil prices rose and hydraulic fracturing technology advanced in the 2000s, tapping the ocean of crude suddenly made good economic sense. North Dakota went from being the ninth biggest oil-producing state in 2006 to the second today, with only Texas producing more. There are now more than 9,000 active wells in the state, producing 800,000 barrels of oil a day — about 11 percent of the country’s overall production.

What has that brought to North Dakota?
Jobs, money, and people. The state now has the lowest unemployment rate in the country, at 3 percent. Its oil industry employs almost 41,000 people, plus 18,000 jobs in peripheral industries. For those working in the “Oil Patch” in the western part of the state, the average annual salary is $112,462. The only requirements to find work are a government-issued ID and a clean criminal record. This modern gold rush has lured people from all over America to North Dakota, once one of the country’s most sparsely populated states. Terry Ayers drove to Williston in 2011 from Spokane and got an oil job within hours of arriving, earning around three times what he had been making before. “It’s a zoo,” he said then. “It’s crazy what’s going on around here.”

Has that been good for the state?
For the economy, it’s been terrific. The estimated $34.4 billion North Dakota has reaped in revenue from the boom has given it the healthiest balance sheet in the country, with an enviable $1.6 billion budget surplus. But the flood of money and new residents has also caused some severe growing pains. North Dakota’s population leaped 7.7 percent in six years. Some small towns have been inundated with new residents; Watford City, for example, went from 1,744 residents to 7,500, including 28 registered sex offenders. The state’s infrastructure is buckling under the strain. Housing has become scarce and expensive. Heavy truck traffic has put a strain on the state’s roads and bridges, which need an additional $350 million a year for upkeep. Sewage plants are running over capacity, due to new residents and a flood of fracking wastewater. The region’s health-care providers are being overwhelmed by scores of workers injured while carrying out dangerous manual jobs. “My work has now been transformed from that of a small family practitioner to basically an ER doc,” said Gary Ramage, a physician at McKenzie County Hospital.

Who are these new residents?
Most are single young men lured from other states by the promise of big paychecks. They’ve transformed once-sleepy small towns, peeling off wads of bills to spend in local bars and strip clubs — and in some cases, on methamphetamine and prostitutes. Williston’s population has doubled since 2010, from 15,000 to over 30,000. Most of these workers live in temporary housing known locally as “man-camps,” rows of trailers with communal cafeterias and bathrooms, not unlike a military camp. There are 17 man-camps in Williston alone. To cut down on fighting and crime, the oil companies now enforce strict rules on man-camp residents, with a zero tolerance policy for drugs, alcohol, and firearms. “I look at man-camps as being somewhat a necessary evil,” said E. Ward Koeser, president of the Williston City Commission.

What do longtime North Dakotans think?
They welcome the infusion of money, but not what comes with it. The cost of living has surged; stores and restaurants have raised prices so they can pay wages of up to $20 an hour to compete with the high-paying oil jobs. High housing demand and skyrocketing rents across the state have also pushed thousands onto the streets, including many newcomers who failed to keep jobs. Homelessness in North Dakota has almost tripled since 2010. In Williston, the Salvation Army has resorted to buying homeless men one-way bus tickets. “Sometimes, they’re better off going back home,” said Salvation Army employee Joshua Stansbury.

Can the state adjust to the boom?
County legislatures are clamoring for the state to spend some of its budget surplus on new hospitals, infrastructure, and affordable housing. But many state lawmakers remember how quickly oil fortunes can come and go; the state’s oil industry tanked after oil prices collapsed in the 1990s, leaving many western counties still paying off debts run up during the 1980s boom. If the current boom ends for some unforeseen reason, state officials fear, they’ll wind up with empty medical centers, unused freeways, and empty housing developments. “When Mr. Bakken comes to town, no one can prepare,” said Brad Bekkedahl, vice president of the Bismarck City Commission. “It’s a good challenge to have, and there’s a lot of people that wish they had it. But it’s a challenge.”

A state full of men
Nine out of 10 workers lured by North Dakota’s boom are men. But there is one peripheral industry attracting women to the Oil Patch: exotic dancing. Strippers can bank over $2,000 a night in oil boomtowns. “It’s all but guaranteed money,” said Susan Shepard, a dancer who worked in Williston for six years. Prostitution is also on the rise, according to law enforcement authorities. Hospitals note that rates of chlamydia doubled between 2010 and 2011. Local women have also complained that the roving bands of unattached, restless young men have created a culture of constant sexual harassment. Williston tattoo artist Christina Knapp, 22, recalled being offered $3,000 to strip naked and serve beer to a group of men. When she refused, the men upped the offer to $7,000. “I said I make more money doing my job than degrading myself to do that,” she said.

 
Dan Stewart is a senior editor at The Week magazine. Originally from the U.K., he has been living in the United States since 2009.
Posted in Bakken | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Absarokee: A 21st century Deadwood?

As you get into complicated political issues, you try to figure out what they really mean for the quality of life in an area. One of the comparisons I’ve often seen for Red Lodge is Williston, ND, at the heart of the Bakken oil and gas development area. I’ve seen the comment, “We don’t want another Williston” several times.
 
So I looked up Williston. It was a sleepy town of about 10,000 before the fracking boom. It now approaches 30,000. High paying jobs are plentiful. There’s a housing boom that can’t keep up with the growth.
 

So what’s not to like?

A lot of crime for one thing. Rape and theft have increased dramatically. Most disturbing is crimes against women.  This NY Times article and this one from the Twin Cities highlight the issues women face when the population growth is almost exclusively male. One quote I ran into was, “This is the Wild Wild West.”

So what does this mean for Red Lodge? To begin with, the current population is only 2155, so it doesn’t have anywhere near the growth capacity of Williston. That means workers would live not only in Red Lodge, but in Roscoe, Fishtail, Nye and Absarokee as well. They will become boom towns, and they will change dramatically.

My initial concern about this was environmental, and I’m still concerned. I’m now getting that this is going to be a huge issue for life as we know it on the Stillwater. Imagine Absarokee as a 21st century Deadwood.

My level of alarm has gone way up since I started looking into this.

Posted in Community Organization, Politics and History, Fracking Information | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Some Updates

  • I spoke to Maggie Zaback at Northern Plains Resource Council today. She put me on the listserv for the Carbon County Resource Council so I’ll get all the inside stuff. They’re about to announce a Beartooth Defense Fund campaign to pay for their operations on this issue. Their strategy will be multi-pronged: legislative, communication and PR, legal, etc, so there will be an opportunity to donate to support them. She’s very nice and willing to chat. It would be nice if we could figure out something we could do to help. Her contact info.
  • Jonathan sends along an article from USA Today that reports a study finding that the economic returns to fracked wells diminish quickly. Seems controversial, but I’d been focusing on the environmental issues and it appears that there could be an economic basis to fight this thing too. I really didn’t understand how much oil and gas production has increased because of fracking, but the bottom line is that no matter how good the technology gets, there’s still a finite amount of fossil fuels to pull out of the ground. We need to be shifting to clean energy. Article is here.
  • Aunt Big Jane sends along a couple of letters to the editor in the Gazette: Here and here. And she’s already been recruited to help at the Cowboy Supper the NPRC meetings in a couple weeks. Still got to get Tom to do some Shakespeare for the crowd.
  • And here’s something you can do right this second. The Red Lodge paper has a poll on fracking in the middle of their front page. If everybody clicks right now, we ought to be able to rig this thing. Vote here.
  • The Red Lodge Paper also has an extensive article about the planned drilling with lots of information not in the Gazette article. Here.
  • There’s also a map of existing wells by status here. If anybody can figure out how to read this, let us know. It looks to me like there is only one producing well in Stillwater County, but I’m not sure.
Posted in Community Organization, Politics and History | Leave a comment
I got my membership packet from the Northern Plains Resource Council. I guess my membership in the Carbon County Resource Council gets me membership in the umbrella organization as well.

It’s a very impressive packet, which comes with the quarterly newspaper, full of information about important conservation topics and other issues. Here’s what I’ve got to report:

  • The annual meeting of the NPRC is in Billings at the Crowne Plaza on November 15-16.
    • Friday, November 15, 1:30 – 5:00, General Meeting. No charge. This is where they consider resolutions from the membership about strategic initiatives
    • Saturday monrning, 8:30 – 10:00, $10 for Sat. morning meetings. “The Next 20 years: Montana’s Water in the Era of Oil and Gas Development.” This seems like the highlight related to the fracking issue.
    • Lots of other good stuff, including a cowboy dinner on Friday.
  • Something for all to do: the Water Resources Division of the Montana Department of Natural Resources and Conservation is required by the Montana Legislature to do a 20-year update to the Montana State Water Plan. They are seeking public input. For the Yellowstone Basin, send comments to jrobinson@mt.gov. Key points to make:
    • Oil and gas development uses large amounts of fresh water. However, there is no signle state agency that documents the amount of water used and lost to the system by oil and gas development. Without this oversight, water resources for agriculture and recreation will likely be depleted.
    • The State of Montana is currently promoting water marketing without truly gauging how much water is available. The 2013 Legislature enacted a law that would incentivize leasing any excess wather that rights holders have. This will reduce the water supply by an unknown amount, potentially disastrously.
    • This is a big one: the state has regulations that provide for minimal chemical disclosure, However, most of the chemicals used in oil and gas drilling are still kept secret. This makes it hard to do any accurate baseline water testing, increasing the risk that the runoff from fracking will harm the soil and water table.
    • Write today.
  • You really should join the Northern Plains Resource Council through the Carbon County Resource Council or the Stillwater Protective Association. They are very dependent on memberships for their operations. There is an option to do a monthly payment of about $3.50, deducted from your bank account. To set this up, call Caleb (no last name, like Madonna) at 406-248-1154.
  • If you haven’t signed the petition yet, please do it, and get your friends to sign as well. They’ve got about 1300 signatures so far, which seems like a lot fewer than will be required to hold off a billion dollar drilling operation.
Posted on by davidjkatz | Leave a comment

A Dad’s Frack of the Day

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment