How drilling tramples on property rights and lowers home values

rural fracking2One myth about oil and gas drilling is that it creates riches in a community in the form of increased property values. “With all the new jobs,” the industry says, “buyers will be falling all over themselves to buy your property.” Not true.

Over the next three days I’m going to look at how the expansion of oil and gas drilling in a community actually lowers property values, reduces the ability of property owners to borrow against their property and prevents them from obtaining insurance against the damage drilling causes.

One important thing to understand about fracking is that it has brought drilling closer to the homes of more and more Americans. The technology is so much more efficient than conventional drilling that it is now more economical to drill in places where it was never possible to do so before. According to the Wall Street Journal, more than 15 million Americans now live within a mile of an oil or gas well. If you are one of the 20,000 people living in Stillwater or Carbon County this is not good news.

Most properties in our part of Montana are split estates — the surface rights are split from the mineral rights. The mineral rights are dominant, so if you don’t own the rights to oil and gas under your land, you get very little benefit from having the drillers extract oil from your property, and the damage they do in getting it out — even if it’s on a neighbor’s property — devalues your home and your land.

rural frackingAnd there’s really not much you can do to protect your property rights from the oil and gas companies. They traditionally pay a small one-time fee for access (although not always), it’s very difficult to get compensation for the direct damage they do to your property, and it’s impossible to protect yourself against the devaluation of property in the community when it becomes the site of heavy industry associated with drilling.

There’s now clear evidence that drilling destroys property values. Read on.

  • In a 2013 survey of 550 people in Texas, Alabama and Florida, a strong majority said they would decline to buy a home near drilling site. The study, published in the Journal of Real Estate Literature, also showed that people bidding on homes near fracking locations reduced their offers by up to 25 percent. The bottom line conclusion of the study, is that drilling drops home values by 5-15%. It’s logical that this would be the case. Why would you pay top dollar when you’ve got a noisy business running next door that fouls the air and threatens your water.
  • Realtors in Colorado are documenting that buyers are becoming increasingly hesitant about buying homes near drilling sites, with fewer and fewer bids rolling in. “Some don’t want to even look at anything remotely close to any existing or proposed well sites,” Boulder County real estate agent Nanner Fisher told the Colorado Independent. She also told the Boulder Journal that “if there is a well that’s visible when you show a property, the prospective buyer will ask to look for something else. A lot of it is the visual effect of the well site,” she said. “And, they think if you can see it, it’s gotta be close enough that it’s not healthy.”
  • Denver Realtor Adam Cox wrote in a column in the Colorado Statesman that “potential buyers balk at buying homes near a drilling site, even though that’s often where the discounted homes are” because they are so close to oil and gas activity. Similarly, he said, homeowners near drilling sites “often have to sell at significantly lower prices than when originally purchased due to the oil and gas industry neighbors.”
  • In Pavilion, Wyo., where the EPA has linked groundwater contamination with fracking, Louis Meeks saw the value of his 40-acre alfalfa farm all but disappear completely. In 2006, his land and home were appraised at $239,000. Two years later, as ProPublica reported, “a local realtor sent Meeks a letter saying his place was essentially worthless and she could not list his property. ‘Since the problem was well documented … and since no generally-accepted reason for the blowout has been agreed upon,’ she wrote, ‘buyers may feel reluctant to purchase a property with this stigma.’ ”
  • A study conducted by researchers at Duke University found that the risks and potential liabilities of drilling outweigh economic benefits like lease payments and potential economic development in Washington County, PA. Even though lease payments can add overall value to homes with wells drilled on them, the possibility of contaminated water decreases property value by an average of 24 percent. The boost that comes from signing a lease offsets the increases, leaving a net decrease in value of 13 percent. But keep in mind that the lease payments assume that the estate is unified — something much more common in the East than in Montana.
  • A 2010 study of the Texas real estate market in the heavily drilled suburban-Dallas area near Flower Mound concluded that homes valued at more than $250,000 and within 1,000 feet of a drilling pad or well site saw values decrease by 3 to 14 percent.
  • Faced with a boom in coal-bed methane development in the early 2000s, officials in La Plata County, Colorado studied the impacts of oil and gas development and found that properties with a well drilled on them saw their value decrease by 22 percent.
  • In a 2005 peer-reviewed study, researchers found that oil and gas production “significantly affect the sale price for rural properties.” The study determined that the presence of oil and gas facilities within 2.5 miles of rural residential properties in Alberta, Canada reduced property values between 4% and 8%, with the potential for doubling the decrease, depending on the level of industrial activity.
  • In Montana, where the oil and gas industry gets a tax holiday, surface owners wind up subsidizing them by paying property taxes on the land the drillers are using to get the oil. It’s a hidden cost, and as a taxpayer you pay and they don’t.

If you don’t know whether you own the mineral rights under your property, you need to find out. If you do, it’s possible (but not guaranteed) that the lease payments will offset your losses. If you don’t, you are vulnerable to having your property rights trampled on by oil and gas companies.

Tomorrow I’ll be looking at how drilling impacts your ability to get a mortgage.

About davidjkatz

The Moses family has lived on the Stillwater River since 1974, when George and Lucile Moses retired and moved to the Beehive from the Twin Cities. They’re gone now, but their four daughters (pictured at left, on the Beehive) and their families continue to spend time there, and have grown to love the area. This blog started as an email chain to keep the family informed about the threat of increased fracking activity in the area, but the desire to inform and get involved led to the creation of this blog.
This entry was posted in Fracking Information and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to How drilling tramples on property rights and lowers home values

  1. Pingback: Mortgage lenders increasingly worried about fracking | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  2. Pingback: The deck is stacked against property owners who seek compensation for damages done by oil and gas drilling | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  3. Pingback: Bad news. Your property value is about to go down 22% | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  4. Pingback: A safer approach to drilling? Not for us. | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  5. davidjkatz says:

    Thanks for stopping in. Come back soon — I update often.

  6. Pingback: Betting on 21-85-16. Playing lotto with our future | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  7. Pingback: Colorado court decision favoring the oil and gas industry could actually be good news for us along the Beartooth Front | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  8. Pingback: Citizen initiated zoning: a way to restore fairness to oil and gas drilling in Montana | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  9. Pingback: Meeting today in Red Lodge! Frequently Asked Questions about the Silvertip citizen-initiated zone | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  10. Pingback: $1 million award to North Dakota ranch could influence future judgments against oil companies | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  11. Pingback: Oil and gas: 10 lessons for 2015 | Preserve the Beartooth Front

  12. Pingback: Oil and gas: 10 lessons for 2015, for Montana, ND, OK, TX, OH, PA & WV

  13. Pingback: Action Alert: Your voice is needed to put strong Montana setback rules into place | Preserve the Beartooth Front

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s